Book Review: Coven by Soman Chainani

Title: Coven

Author: Soman Chainani

Series/Standalone: Standalone

Genre: Fantasy, Young Adult, Graphic Novel

Pages: 272

Publisher: HarperAlley

Year Published: 2025

Format: Paperback Copy (Library Copy)

"Need your magical crime solved?

Call the Witch Coven.

Hester, Anadil, and Dot are legendary across the Endless Woods are vigilante detectives and protectors of the peace. The famed trio are not only talented witches but also ride-or-die friends who've never left a case unsolved.

That is until the Coven answers a call for help from a mysterious new world- Red Isle, where the Light and Dark Lands are on the brink of all-out-war, each blaming the other for a grim spree of deaths. Now the Coven must work together and unmask the killer before Red Isle tears itself apart. Little do they know: The real enemy might be hiding in plain sight..."

My Rating: 4/5

This was such an interesting read. I didn't realize that it was connected to the middle grade school for good and evil books. This was a great book to flip through.  The art was fun, the idea was heavy-handed but great, and overall, such a quick, great read. Loved it.

Thanks for reading,

Sidny

Book Review: Coven by Jennifer Dugan

Title: Coven

Author: Jennifer Dugan

Illustrator: Kit Seaton

Series/Standalone: Standalone

Genre: Graphic Novels, Urban Fantasy, YA

Pages: 288

Publisher: GP Putnam's Sons Books for Young Readers

Year Published: 2022

Format: Hardcover (Library Copy)

"Emsy has always lived in sunny California, and she'd much rather spend her days surfing with her friends or hanging out with her girlfriend than honing her powers as a fire elemental. But when members of her family's coven back east are murdered under mysterious circumstances that can only be the result of powerful witchcraft, her family must suddenly return to dreary upstate New York. There, Emsy will have to master her neglected craft in order to find the killer... before her family becomes their next target."

My Rating: 1.5/5

This was not for me and I'm beginning to wonder if I'm missing some other lore or information. Is this part of a series? A spin-off of a famous show or a retelling of some kind? I really wanted to like it but I just found that I was bored throughout the entirety and it felt as though at some points I was in the middle of a series that I hadn't started at the beginning of. Does anyone out there know?

Thanks for reading,

Sidny